Vergangenheitsbewältigung ("coming to terms with the past") is a key word for understanding the success of democracy in post-war Germany. Germany confronted its historical responsibility for the crimes of the Nazi era, and as a result the principles of enlightened democracy were embraced. Unfortunately, the process for the most part did not take place in the eastern states of the former GDR, and as a consequence both right-wing extremism and authoritarian leftism are prevalent in the region.
But the process of Vergangenheitsbewältigung is also needed for Russia and the former Soviet satellite states. The Russian philosophy professor Michail Ryklin sees the roots of the conflict in the Caucusus as the outcome of insufficient Vergangenheitsbewältigung in an important essay that appears in Die Zeit:
Und überhaupt: Wer sind diese »Russen« und »Georgier« eigentlich? Vor allem
sind sie alle postsowjetische Menschen, denen es nur so scheint, als seien sie
nach dem großen Terror in ihre nationalen Nischen zurückgekehrt – ganz so, als
hätte der Terror bei ihnen keine tiefen Wunden hinterlassen, die noch
jahrzehntelang nicht ausheilen werden, als würden sie am Körper ihrer Nation
keine Phantomschmerzen aus der Sowjetzeit spüren. […} Dieser Unwille, sich mit der eigenen Geschichte auseinanderzusetzen, beschert
dem postsowjetischen Raum Kriege und ethnische Konflikte. Unabhängig von der
jeweiligen Rhetorik blüht der Nationalismus, wobei auch die demokratische
Rhetorik keine Ausnahme bildet.Eine Rückkehr nach Europa ist nur durch die Auseinandersetzung mit der
jüngsten totalitären Geschichte möglich, mit jenen Mechanismen, die
Russen, Ukrainer, Weißrussen, Kirgisen und Georgier gleichermaßen
unterjocht haben. Erst wenn diese Arbeit getan ist, werden unsere
Vorstellungen von Europa komplexer, differenzierter und – was das
Wichtigste ist – realistischer, auch wenn sie dann nicht so hochtrabend
klingen werden wie die der »Übereuropäer«.
(And who are these ‘Russians’ and ‘Georgians’
anyway? Most of them are post-Soviet people who think they have returned to
their national niches after the end of the Great Terror – as if the Terror had
not left them with deep wounds that would take decades to heal, as if their
nation would not feel the phantom pains of the Soviet era. … The refusal
to confront their own past is bringing wars and conflict to the post-Soviet
region. Regardless of the form the rhetoric takes nationalism is flourishing,
and democratic rhetoric is no exception here. … A return to Europe can only
be achieved by confronting the recent totalitarian past and those mechanisms
that reduced the Russians, Ukrainians, Belarusians, Kyrgyz and Georgians to the
same servitude. Only when this work has been done can our concepts of Europe
become more complex, nuanced and – what is more important – realistic.)

0 comment
You are very, very wrong with your opinion about eastern Germany… shows that you really never were in Germany and don’t understand it a bit. Your idea about “authoritarian leftism” is really “drollig” too because nothing like that even exists here.
Honestly I think the only people who will need PTSD treatment against the incurred terror are those who are currently being “liberated” by your country.
You should also be aware that this theory about “totalitarism” is although not outright Holocaust denial, one of the ultra-rightwing/neoliberal theories that seek to downplay the Nazi dictatorship and equate it with all forms of social democracy.
Maybe those poor people who found the nasty side of that book review of yours were really onto something there… glad you managed to silence them in the name of American free speech.
I’ve been reading remarks from certain leaders of the LEFT party that praise the old SED. Stalinism is alive and well.
You’re wrong again. Of course our current chancellor Ms.Merckel is a former SED propaganda functionary from the very elite of theirs.
Her party has also taken in the old Stalinists from the Blockpartei eastern CDU and many power-conscious SED-Stalinists switched to them at a moments notice 🙂
So what remains is an old man complaining that eastern Europe needs more of that ‘natural’ nationalism, please. The desperation meter keeps rising…